Lesson 4 of 10
Discernment I: Looking Inward with Jung
What you will learn
- 1Define discernment and explain why it begins with self-knowledge.
- 2Describe the shadow, projection and the Trickster in plain language.
- 3Hold hard facts about your thing without tipping into denial or despair.
Dr. Dalton's talk
Reading
Knowing Your Own Mind First
Awe opens the door. Discernment is what you do once you are inside. The word means the ability to tell things apart: true from false, what you were told from what you actually observed, what matters from what merely shouts. One Simple Thing defines it as knowing the difference between what you have been told and what you have actually observed.
This course spends three lessons on discernment. The next two look outward, at evidence and at the internet. This one looks inward, because Jung taught that the first obstacle to seeing clearly is not out there. It is in us.
Why Jung starts inside
Jung wrote that every advance in culture is an extension of consciousness, and that it can take place only through discrimination, his word for discernment. Before we can sort the world, he believed, we have to sort ourselves. His most quoted line on the subject comes from a letter: "Who looks outside, dreams; who looks inside, awakes."
Dr. Dalton's dissertation identifies three inner forces that get in the way of clear seeing. Jung named the first two. The third comes from Algonquian tradition and is covered in Lesson 6.
The shadow
The shadow is Jung's name for everything about ourselves we would rather not see. It holds our greed, envy, laziness, prejudice and fear, pushed out of awareness because they do not match the person we want to be. Everyone has one. Jung's point was that the shadow does not go away when ignored. It gains energy, and then it steers us from behind.
How does this affect discernment? A person who cannot admit their own wastefulness will find it hard to read honestly about waste. A person who needs to feel virtuous will collect only the facts that flatter them. Dr. Dalton writes candidly that during his research he had to confront his own greed, selfishness and pride while thinking of himself as generous. He does not present that as a failure. He presents it as the work.
Jung also offered a kindness here. To show a person their shadow, he wrote, is also to show them their light. When you look honestly at your faults you notice your strengths too, and you can say with some relief that you are not as bad as all that.
Projection
The shadow has a favorite trick, which Jung called projection. What we cannot see in ourselves, we see vividly in others. If I have not faced my own carelessness, I become furious at careless people. If I have not faced my own fear, I mock people who are afraid.
In the dissertation Jung is quoted as saying that when an inner situation is not made conscious, it happens outside, as fate. For someone learning about a threatened living thing, projection is a constant temptation. It is easy to pour all blame onto a villain: a company, a generation, a political side. Sometimes blame is partly deserved. But a person lost in blame has stopped learning. A facilitator watches for the moment when curiosity turns into contempt, and gently brings the conversation back to the living thing itself.
This is one reason the practice is nonpartisan. A good question to keep handy is, "What do we actually know?"
The Trickster
The Trickster is one of the archetypes, Jung's term for the deep patterns of human experience that appear in myths and dreams across cultures. The Trickster is the disrupter: the coyote, the fool, the joker. In daily life, Trickster energy shows up as distraction, temptation and the appeal to ego. It offers fame, excitement and shortcuts.
Dr. Dalton tells a story on himself. While writing his dissertation chapter on the Trickster, he received a late-night call offering him months of work as a stand-in on a major film about a trickster character. The work was flattering and it paid, and it pulled him away from his writing for four months. He came to see the offer as the Trickster appearing in his own life.
The important thing about the Trickster is that it cuts both ways. Followed blindly, it leads to vanity and wasted time. Met with discernment, it reveals what we secretly want and shakes us out of stale habits. The dissertation says that the rush of excitement must be tempered with judgment. When something dazzling pulls you away from your thing, ask what it is appealing to.
Holding the tension of opposites
When you learn the truth about your thing, you will meet facts that hurt. Populations falling. Habitat shrinking. You will also meet facts that give hope. Jung called the strain of holding two opposing truths the tension of opposites. Most people escape it by collapsing to one side. Some choose denial: it cannot be that bad. Others choose despair: nothing can be done. Both are ways of ending the discomfort, and both stop action.
Jung's advice was to stay in the tension without choosing a side too early. If you can, something new tends to emerge that honors both truths. He called this the transcendent function: a third position, wider than either of the two you started with. For a steward it often sounds like this: "My thing is in real trouble, and there are specific things that help, and I can do one of them."
That sentence is neither denial nor despair. It is discernment.
Discernment as a practice
Dr. Dalton's dissertation describes the goal as a life in which a person, aware of their shadow, uses discernment and intention to direct their thoughts and actions. Here is a simple inner check you can teach.
- Notice the reaction. When you read something about your thing, what do you feel first?
- Name it. Anger, fear, guilt, smugness, relief. Naming a feeling loosens its grip.
- Ask what it wants. Does the feeling want you to learn more, or to stop looking?
- Return to the thing. What is actually true about this living thing, as far as you can tell?
A facilitator does not analyze other people's shadows. That is not your role, and it would break trust. Your job is to do this work on yourself and to keep the room honest, calm and curious.
Key terms
- Discernment: telling apart what is true from what is false, and what you observed from what you were told.
- Shadow: the parts of ourselves we prefer not to see.
- Projection: seeing in others what we have not faced in ourselves.
- Trickster: the archetype of disruption and distraction, which can mislead or awaken.
- Tension of opposites / transcendent function: holding two truths until a wider view appears.
Recommended reading
- The Undiscovered Self, by C. G. Jung (1958). Jung's short, late book for general readers on why the individual who knows themself is the best defense against mass thinking.
- Owning Your Own Shadow: Understanding the Dark Side of the Psyche, by Robert A. Johnson (1991). A brief, clear introduction to the shadow by a Jungian analyst, written for people with no background in psychology.
Practice this week
Write down one threat your thing faces. Notice your first reaction: anger, blame, sadness, looking away. Just notice it.
Ready to test your understanding?
10 questions — you need 8 or more correct to pass.