Course

Lesson 6 of 10

Discernment III: Distraction and Lies Online

What you will learn

  • 1Explain why false and upsetting content spreads quickly online.
  • 2Apply the four SIFT moves and lateral reading to check a claim.
  • 3Describe Wetiko and Jung's warning about "psychic epidemics," and name the defense he proposed.

Dr. Dalton's talk

Dr. Dalton's talk for this lesson is coming soon. You can continue with the reading below.

Reading

Keeping Your Attention and Your Honesty

The internet is the greatest library ever built. It is also the greatest machine ever built for wasting time and spreading falsehood. A steward needs the first and has to survive the second. This lesson gives you tools for both.

Why falsehood travels fast

In 2018 three researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology published a study in the journal Science. They traced about 126,000 news stories shared on Twitter over more than a decade. False stories were 70 percent more likely to be reshared than true ones, and true stories took about six times as long to reach 1,500 people. Automated accounts were not the main cause. People were. False stories tended to be more novel and stirred more surprise and disgust, and people pass along what startles them.

This sits on top of how platforms earn money. Most are free because they sell advertising, so they are built to hold your attention as long as possible. The software that chooses what you see next, the algorithm, learns what keeps people looking. Outrage, fear and conflict keep people looking. Nobody had to plan for the feed to tilt toward alarm. It is simply what the system rewards.

Wetiko and the psychic epidemic

Dr. Dalton's dissertation gives this problem an older name. Wetiko is a concept from Algonquian peoples, brought into current discussion by the writer Paul Levy. It describes a spirit of greed, selfishness and consumption that can take hold of a mind and pass from one person to another, something like a virus of thought. The dissertation argues that social media has made this contagion faster than at any time in history.

Jung, who lived through two world wars, saw the same danger without the technology. He warned that we are on guard against contagious diseases of the body but careless about the collective diseases of the mind. He called them psychic epidemics, and he thought them more destructive than natural disasters. He also observed that a person in a crowd is, without knowing it, a worse person than when alone, because the crowd carries them and relieves them of responsibility. An online pile-on is a crowd.

Jung's defense was not to flee society. It was to become, in his words, as "well organized in his individuality as the mass itself." That is the purpose of Lesson 4's inner work and this lesson's outer habits. A person who knows their own mind and has a method for checking claims is hard to stampede.

Distraction: the quieter problem

Lies are one hazard. Distraction is the other, and it may cost more. Every hour spent scrolling is an hour not spent watching your creek, reading about your owl, or writing your letter. This is Lesson 4's Trickster with a touchscreen, offering small excitements in exchange for your purpose.

Jung feared a time when the whole of reality would be replaced by words. He thought city dwellers were already losing their instincts. A steward's protection is simple: real contact with the real thing. Go outside. No article about a heron substitutes for ten minutes with a heron.

Some practical defenses:

  • Decide before you open. Know what you are looking for and close the app when you have it.
  • Turn off notifications that are not from people you know.
  • Notice the hook. When you feel a jolt of outrage or fear, pause. That jolt is how you are being steered.
  • Keep a ratio. For every hour online about your thing, spend some time with it or doing something for it.

SIFT: four moves for checking a claim

The digital literacy researcher Mike Caulfield developed a short method called SIFT. It takes a minute or two and is designed for real life.

  • S: Stop. Before you read on, believe or share, pause. Do you know this source? What is your emotional reaction?
  • I: Investigate the source. Find out who is behind it. What is their expertise and their aim?
  • F: Find better coverage. See whether trusted sources report the same thing. If nobody reliable is saying it, be careful.
  • T: Trace it to the original. Follow the claim, quote or image back to where it began. Is the original in context? Does it say what the post says it says?

Lateral reading

The second move deserves a closer look. Researchers at Stanford University, led by Sam Wineburg, compared how professional fact-checkers, historians and university students judged unfamiliar websites. The historians and students mostly stayed on the page. They read it carefully and judged it by its design, its "About" section and its tone. They were often fooled. The fact-checkers did something different. They left the site almost at once, opened new tabs, and searched for what others said about the source. They were faster and far more accurate.

This is called lateral reading: instead of reading down the page, you read across the web. A site cannot be trusted to describe itself. Anyone can buy a professional design and write a noble mission statement. What you want to know is what independent sources say about the people behind it.

Red flags

  • No author named, no date, no sources.
  • Strong emotional language: "shocking," "they don't want you to know."
  • A quote or statistic with no link to where it came from.
  • An image that might be from a different time or place. A reverse image search will often find the original.
  • Content that looks or sounds real but has no trace elsewhere. Images, audio and video can now be generated by software, so a convincing picture is no longer proof.
  • A claim that fits perfectly with what you already wanted to believe. This is the most dangerous flag, because it is the one you are least likely to check.

Do not become a cynic

There is a trap on the far side of this lesson. A person who learns that much online content is unreliable may decide nothing can be trusted. That is not discernment. It is another form of giving up, and it leaves a person just as easy to mislead. Discernment means sorting, which requires believing that some things are true and can be found.

Change the feed

The dissertation does not end its discussion of Wetiko with a warning. It ends with an assignment. If feeds reward what people share, then sharing changes feeds. Its recommendation is to share moments of joy, wonder and gratitude, and true stories of encounters with living things, and to notice and pass along those that others share. The dissertation calls this elevating the "meme space" of the internet.

That is a facilitator's work too. Every honest, sourced, hopeful story you share about a living thing is a small correction to the current. Before you post, ask three questions. Is it true? Can I name the source? Does it invite people in, or only alarm them?

Key terms

  • Algorithm: software that selects what you see, usually tuned to hold attention.
  • Wetiko: an Algonquian concept of a contagious spirit of greed and consumption.
  • Psychic epidemic: Jung's term for a harmful idea or mood spreading through a population.
  • SIFT: Stop, Investigate the source, Find better coverage, Trace to the original.
  • Lateral reading: leaving a site to see what other sources say about it.

Recommended reading

  • Verified: How to Think Straight, Get Duped Less, and Make Better Decisions about What to Believe Online, by Mike Caulfield and Sam Wineburg (2023). The creators of SIFT and the lateral reading research explain their methods with many worked examples.
  • The Shallows: What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains, by Nicholas Carr (2010; updated 2020). A careful account of how constant online distraction affects attention and deep reading.

Practice this week

Find one online claim about your thing. SIFT it. Write down what you found.

Ready to test your understanding?

10 questions — you need 8 or more correct to pass.